Environmental Petition

Introducing the “Heavy Vehicle Vision Standard” (HVVS) for heavy vehicles

29 Signatures Obtained, This Campaign Ended on June 12, 2021
29
Signatures
obtained
Help us to reach our target!
29

Target: 1000

Description

A fatal traffic accident happened in Tong Yan San Tsuen Road, Yuen Long on 28th January. A male cyclist was caught under a left-turning heavy vehicle. The driver did not see the cyclist passing by who was out of the driver’s field of vision [A].

The blind spots of heavy vehicles endanger the lives of other road users especially the vulnerable groups including cyclists and pedestrians. According to Hong Kong Police Force, vehicle blind spots are often the main cause of serious pedestrian accidents [B].

This accident reveals that most of the heavy vehicles in Hong Kong do not have sufficient vision equipment – one of the main reasons for fatal traffic accidents. Hong Kong needs a system to ensure adequate, up-to-date safety equipment is used by heavy vehicles. A comprehensive vision standard for heavy vehicles could help protect the lives of drivers and other road users.

References:

[A] Elderly Hong Kong cyclist dies at scene after collision with dump truck in Yuen Long. SCMP.

[B] 中重型貨車盲點多 行人車前3米過路較安全. 成報. [Chinese only]

[1] A Literature Review of Lateral Protection Devices on Trucks Intended for Reducing Pedestrian and Cyclist Fatalities 

[2] Direct Vision Standard and HGV Safety Permit. Transport for London

[3] Phasing Out Euro IV Diesel Commercial Vehicles – Ex-gratia Payment Scheme

Petition Letter

To Commissioner for Transport,

A fatal traffic accident involving a cyclist and a truck driver in Yuen Long on 28th January has come to our attention. We urge the Transport Department to establish a “Heavy Vehicle Vision Standard” (HVVS) to secure the safety of all road users and work towards ‘Vision Zero’ – an international approach that aims at zero fatality and serious injury from road accidents.

As a local group concerning Hong Kong’s transport planning and urban design, we advocate for positive changes with a vision that street planning and design in Hong Kong will be people centred and friendly to vulnerable road users such as pedestrians and cyclists.

Starting from 2022, the installation of side guard systems such as side-facing radar across the European Union will be mandatory for all heavy vehicles. A study estimates that side guard systems can reduce pedestrian and pedal cyclist fatalities by 50 to 74 percent and 17 to 27 percent respectively [1]. In 2019 Transport for London of the United Kingdom launched the Direct Vision Standard and the heavy goods vehicles safety permit system which will be enforced from March 2021 [2]. All heavy vehicles over 12 tons must fulfill certain safety standards and apply for a permit to enter the city, otherwise, drivers may be subject to penalty.

Taking reference from the Direct Vision Standard, we propose a “Heavy Vehicle Vision Standard” (HVVS) to be introduced with a grace period. HVVS is a rating system that grades heavy vehicles based on the installed vision devices such as close-range detectors, side protection devices, rear mirrors, warning alarms, and signs. The grace period allows professional drivers sufficient time to install vision devices. The requirements for fulfilling the standard shall be met at the end of the grace period. An ex-gratia payment scheme should also be organised to provide drivers with financial aid. The vision devices could help avoid traffic and pedestrian accidents related to inner-wheel-difference and blind spots of heavy vehicles.

As the Ex-gratia Payment Scheme under the Environmental Protection Department (EPD) is going to phase out Euro IV diesel commercial vehicles [3], we urge the Transport Department to take this opportunity to launch HVVS. Heavy vehicle drivers can thus consider together the cost of vehicle replacement and installation of vision devices.

Petition Creator

This petition was started by Justin Yim on February 9, 2021, with an end date of June 12, 2021.

‘Street Reset’ is a local concerned group that gathers support for people centred transportation and street planning, to make Hong Kong a more livable city. Through improving street design, ‘Street Reset’s’ vision is for the general public to rely less on private cars and rail, and to use road space more safely.
「街道變革」期望匯聚支持人本交通、改變街道設計嘅共同群體。我們希望香港街道設計,能夠令行人同單車使用者有更合理待遇。路面空間應被善用,令大眾可以減少對私家車與鐵路的依賴。